Quick note: Some links are affiliate links. We earn a tiny commission if you buy (at no cost to you). Keeps the lights on!

climbing shoe
Scarpa

Instinct S

Category
Climbing shoe
Type
Slipper
Key specs
Vibram XS Grip 2, 3.5 mm; M50 heel
Material
Microfiber
Weight
240 g (size 41)

What climbers keep saying · from 17 reviews

great heel hooks5needs break-in5painful4comfortable3precise edging3sensitive3great toe hooks1stretches a lot1

The new Instinct S, one full size down from street, starts very tight but relaxes over a handful of climbing days; synthetic uppers.

positiveneeds break-in

Downsized the Instinct S by 1.5-2 and it was painful at first; toes go numb after 15-20 minutes straight.

mixedpainfulneeds break-in

Their Instinct S in 43 (one size down) is much better for smearing than the VS and doesn't curl the toes as much; softer with stretchier toe rubber.

positive

The Instinct S has a narrower toe box and is a bit stiffer than the VSR, with a softer toe-hook patch; struggled to find a use case and found the toe box uncomfortable.

mixed

The Instinct S can't be tightened: it either fits or it doesn't, and heel hooking pulls the shoe loose.

mixed

Has had multiple pairs of Instinct S: buy the smallest size you can put on new since they stretch over time.

positivestretches a lot

Sized the Instinct S half a size down: brutal to break in and they need to take them off regularly in a gym session, so they mostly live in the bag.

mixedpainful

Closest to a perfect heel fit for their wide forefoot and narrow heel; secure on heel hooks even as a slipper and preferable to the Skwama Women's heel.

positivegreat heel hooks

Has both VSR and S in 39.5: the S feels slightly tighter with a slimmer heel and wraps the midfoot snugly; not much softer than the VSR.

positive

The Instinct S slipper feels stiffer and better at edging than the VSR while still smearing well once broken in.

positiveprecise edging

Broke in their Instinct S in about 3-6 hours of gym bouldering; amazing heel and arch fit.

positiveneeds break-in

Has wide feet with a narrow heel and the Instinct S is one of several Instincts that work for them.

positive

Absolutely loves the Instinct S; fit their foot like a glove out of the box.

positivecomfortable

Got the Instinct S after the VSR and is really happy: superb slippers that edge, smear and even hook; narrower than the VS/VSR and need a bit of break-in.

positiveprecise edgingneeds break-in

Preferred their Instinct S for vertical sport climbing and felt more confident in it.

positive

Finds the Instinct S stiffer than the VSR; the rubber is its only con for them at 90-95 kg.

mixed

Had good luck with the Instinct S fit, though the break-in was miserable.

mixedneeds break-in

Went with the Instinct S slippers and they fulfilled their need for a shallow heel, though quite aggressively downturned.

positivegreat heel hooks

The Instinct S gets into micros with good tension, is great for long sessions and soft enough for sensitivity.

positivesensitiveprecise edging

The Instinct S has an almost perfect heel for them, but its centred forefoot makes their toes hurt.

mixedgreat heel hookspainful

The Instinct S was very stiff under the forefoot and crushed their big toe to the point of injury.

negativepainful

Basically only uses the Instinct S now: big toe patch, a better heel than the regular Instinct, and brilliant sensitivity; size down half from the Instinct.

positivesensitivegreat heel hooksgreat toe hooks

Finds the Instinct S softer and more sensitive than other Instincts thanks to thinner rubber, with a slightly better heel fit and more comfort, though it doesn't last as long.

“Try the Instinct S. thinner rubber, more feels and softer, but still an instinct. For me it fits a little better in the heel and the softness makes it more comfy generally. It doesn’t last as long though.”
mixedsensitivecomfortablewears out fast

With low-volume heels, finds the Instinct S their second-best heel fit after the women's Skwama, about the same as the VSR LV.

positive

Finds the Instinct S has the best heel for them, even as a slipper, and very comfortable.

positivecomfortablegreat heel hooks